Should I Pay Off My House? (Or Let a “Bridge Fund” Do It For Me?)

If you’re familiar with Dave Ramsey, you know his position on paying off your house is always a resounding YES! Of course, you have to get to step 6 of his Baby Steps first, but then no matter what other situation(s) you’re in, the next step is to put all extra cash towards your mortgage. I love Dave Ramsey, and I think the Baby Steps are exactly what everybody needs to be following, but we disagree a little on step 6. Allow me to explain…

I believe the answer is dependent first on just two factors:

  1. Your age and spouse’s age
  2. Size of your retirement fund

If it’s still a green light, then the following come into play:

  1. Age of your mortgage
  2. Mortgage length
  3. Interest rate
  4. How long you believe you’ll be in the house

The Two Gatekeeper Factors: Age and Portfolio Size

First and foremost is how old you and your spouse are, or more specifically, how close you are/aren’t to retirement. An important second is the size of your retirement fund. If you can have your house paid off in your 40s, then by all means do it! That would be amazing! If it’s going to be into your 50s or 60s or later, then let me explore a scenario with you:

At this point, you’re debt-free except for the mortgage. You have a certain amount of extra cash that you can put toward your mortgage each month. Dave Ramsey says that should all go to the mortgage to pay it off ASAP so you can then invest all the extra cash that had been going to the mortgage and then really explode your way to real wealth. 

If the final payoff date, with those extra payments, will be after you retire, then you lose that benefit of investing the freed-up cash because you’re no longer investing, but living off your investments. The same is true if the payoff date is only a few years before retirement.

Am I saying it’s always a mistake to follow that path? If your retirement fund is insufficient, then it really doesn’t seem like a good idea. If your retirement fund is fully loaded and ready to go, then spending your final earning years paying off your house could be a good move. Imagine going into retirement with no mortgage!

The Illusion of Security vs. Actual Liquidity

There’s also the sense of security facet to it all. Certainly, having a paid-off mortgage provides great peace of mind and a sense of security. But what about during the process of paying it off? If all your extra cash is going into the mortgage, it is inaccessible in case of an emergency such as job loss, severe health issues, natural disasters, etc. Yes, by following the Baby Steps, you have 3-6 months’ expenses set aside. But we all know of situations that can last longer than that. However, if you invest that extra cash each month, those funds remain semi-liquid and accessible. To my mind, knowing the money is there to cover your mortgage payment seems to provide a greater peace and sense of security. 

The Bridge Fund Strategy

So here’s an alternate proposal. What about setting up an investment account dedicated to the early payoff of your mortgage? All your extra cash would go in there, invested in a solid mutual fund to reduce risk. Then, once the balance of that account (accounting for estimated capital gains taxes) equals or exceeds the remaining balance on your mortgage, reevaluate the payoff decision in light of current circumstances and potentially withdraw the funds and pay off the mortgage. Investing always carries a greater risk than a straight mortgage principal payment, but a good mutual fund should net around 10% annually. This means the mortgage is actually paid off faster while keeping the funds still accessible. Seems like the best of both worlds to me!

Simple caveat — the higher the mortgage rate, the riskier this approach becomes. 

I will explore this in a follow-up post, looking at where the cutoff might be. I think it will surprise you. For example, a 3% pandemic-era mortgage rate acts vastly differently in this scenario compared to a 7% mortgage rate.  I’ll also explore the remaining 4 green light factors. So look for that!

Disclaimer: This content is for educational and informational purposes only and represents the personal insights of the author. It should not be taken as professional financial, legal, or tax advice. For specific strategies tailored to your unique financial situation, consider consulting with a qualified professional.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *