Pay Off My House? — The Final Green Lights (Part 3)

Should you pay off your mortgage early or let a “Bridge Fund” do it for you? In this final installment of our 3-part series, we wrap things up by looking at the last of the green light factors: how long you believe you’ll be in the house, the age of your mortgage, and mortgage length.

Series Navigation:

In Part 1, I introduced the idea of using a bridge fund as an alternative means for paying off your house early, and explored the feasibility in relation to how old you are and the current size of your retirement portfolio. In Part 2, we went deeper into the whys and why-nots regarding the loan’s interest rate. Today we’ll wrap things up by looking at the last of the green light factors I first laid out in Part 1:

  • Age of your mortgage
  • Mortgage length
  • How long you believe you’ll be in the house

How Long Will You Be in the House?

Let’s look at the last one first. Did you know that the average life of a mortgage is only 7-8 years? (see Hall Financial — What’s the Average Mortgage Length?) Most mortgages start out as 30 years, but very few actually last that long. People often move, or most popularly, they refinance, even several times, either chasing a lower rate, consolidating debt, or both. (Look for a future post about why consolidating debt into your mortgage is usually a bad idea — from experience!)

If you know you’re only going to be there for 5-7 years because you’ll be upgrading to support a growing family, or downgrading for empty nest time or retirement, is it still worth trying to pay down as much as possible? Let’s try a little exercise.

In the first year of a $500,000 30-year mortgage at 6.25%, you’ll pay $31,084.07 in interest and only $5,859.01 will come off the principal. Yikes! Here’s the breakdown on making extra principal payments on that same loan:

At a Glance: Extra Payments on a $500k Mortgage

Adding $100/Month:

  • Year 1: Saves ~$35 in interest. | Shifts +$1,235 to principal.
  • 5 Years: Saves ~$1,200 in interest | Shifts +$7,100 to principal.

Adding $500/Month:

  • Year 1: Saves ~$175 in interest | Shifts +$6,200 to principal.
  • 5 Years: Saves ~$6,000 in interest | Shifts +$36,000 to principal.

So What Does It Mean?

If you’re in a position to pay a significant amount extra each month, that’s a green light. If you’re just starting out and can only do an extra $100/mo, perhaps that’s better put towards retirement investments. 

If you still have consumer debt or student loans, you should put any extra towards those and shouldn’t be thinking about paying off your house in the first place.


Age of Your Mortgage

Now what about the age of the mortgage? We just looked at the first 5 years of a 30-year mortgage. Let’s look at the last 5 years. On that same $500,000, 30-year fixed mortgage at 6.25%, if no extra principal payments have been made, the total interest paid in the last 5 years is $12,796.88. In dollars and cents, that comes out to $213.28 per month in average interest during those final 5 years (compared to over $2,500/month in interest at the start of the loan).

Obviously, extra principal payments have the greatest impact the earlier they’re made. If you’re looking for the peace of mind that comes from a paid-off house, even with only 5 years left, I’d say go for it. From a pure numbers perspective, it’s hardly worth it. Seems the extra payments could do more good in your retirement fund.


Mortgage Length

And the length of the mortgage — our last green light factor? Not really a factor. 😃 Run the numbers and see if all the others flash green, and whether you have a 10-, 15-, or 30-year mortgage, I’d say go for it. That’s just my opinion. 👍

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *