Roth vs. Traditional IRA Calculator
Compare which account type leaves you with more spendable cash in retirement. Assumes an industry-standard 7% annual growth rate, compounded monthly.
Assumptions
Estimated After-Tax Spendable Money
Pay Uncle Sam Today or Tomorrow?
When it comes to retirement accounts, people love to debate Roth versus Traditional like they’re picking sports teams. But behind all the noise, the core difference boils down to a single question: Are you paying taxes today at your current rate, or paying them later in retirement?
Both accounts give you tax shelters. Both allow your investments to grow sheltered from annual capital gains taxes. The winner comes down to the tax bracket spread between where you sit right now and where you land when you retire.
How Both Accounts Work in Plain English
- Traditional IRA (Pay Later): You take a tax deduction on your contributions right now, lowering this year’s tax bill. Your money compounds pre-tax for decades, and every dollar you withdraw in retirement is taxed as ordinary income.
- Roth IRA (Pay Now): You fund the account with after-tax dollars today, so there is no upfront deduction. But once that money is inside, it grows tax-free forever. Every withdrawal in retirement—contributions and earnings—comes out completely free of federal and state income tax.
Making an Apples-to-Apples Comparison
Since Roth contributions must be made with after-tax dollars, that difference has to be accounted for to make the comparison accurate. For the same $6,500 coming out of your paycheck, the entire $6,500 of pre-tax dollars goes into a Traditional IRA. For a Roth IRA, only $4,940 actually makes it into the account after paying income tax upfront (assuming a 24% tax bracket). Modeling that difference shows which option actually leaves you with more spendable cash in retirement.
Dad’s 3 Rules for Picking Your IRA
- In Your 20s or Earning Entry-Level Wages? Go Roth: If you are in the 10% or 12% federal bracket, take the tax hit today while it is minimal. Decades of compounding on tax-free money is an advantage you won’t get later when your income rises.
- In Your Peak Earning Years (24%+)? Lean Traditional: If you are earning healthy six figures, deferring taxes at your current top marginal rate and withdrawing at an effective lower bracket in retirement typically keeps more money in your pocket.
- When in Doubt, Aim for Tax Diversity: You don’t have to pick just one for your entire career. Having both a Traditional bucket (pre-tax) and a Roth bucket (tax-free) gives you control to manage your taxable income bracket when you reach retirement.
Dad’s Bottom Line:
Don’t let tax indecision delay getting started. A slightly less optimal tax account beats letting cash sit in a low-interest checking account every single day of the week.
